Do women meant to do Eid prayer in Mosque?

Hi, im interested in what you say about private and congregational prayer Women are different from men and they need rather different things. Rules were made for men and for women not men and women for the rules. But who should decide what is a good rule?

I'd like to add my perspective. Im from a Christian background but Secular too. While i have a lot of trouble with my Secular societies rules particularly concerning its 'elective democratic' system which i think generally de-selects middle and low incomed people from government and therefore is really an Elective Plutocracy; QED a type of supremacism of the wealthy; yet i also have trouble with the Jewish, Islamic, Christian, Hindu and Sikh theocricies rules which dont treat women as equals in government; QED another supremacism but this time mostly of wealthy male priests.

Each current system seems to me to seek to take advantage of a large part of the population by excluding them from government. I find such behaviour to be childish at best but in general it's degrading to that society. I think each economic class should be allowed to: govern, judge, educate and minister along side each other economic class because i think each economic class is poor in public and private affaires without the other. I also think that women should be allowed to govern, judge, educate and minister alongside men because I think that each sex is poor in public affaires and private affaires without the other. I think it is generally foolish to rely soley on received wisdom and therefor wholly to ignore ones own.

Life is full of contradictions and errors, many of which appear to me to be set up by rather unholy leaders and their exclusive systems of government, Meanwhile i must look to myself as im full of error and contradiction mostly of a secular variety. I recently read an account where a Christian said that he found that the (Roman Catholic) Christian Church to be 'a strange mixture of truth and errors'. The priest shot back, as quick as a flash; 'Yes, God supplies the truth and we supply the errors'.

Well that is the problem; be we secular or faithful we supply the errors, but it is leaders who generally supply more errors than all the rest put together. Therfore i have the deepest reservations both about my own countries leaders and about other countries leaders but also about how i mis-lead myself.

Could do better, is my verdict.

Blessings

James Steel.

Muhammad, SAWS, said to bring the women to masjid for eid. He said the wome are to come for the celebration. He only stipulated that if we are in our menses we are not to attend the eid salaat, but are to participate in everything else. He said even the virgins in purdah are to come for eid. When the sahabah asked about if a woman does not have a veil, he said "Let her borrow the veil of her sister." The Eid salaat is only done in the masjid, so if you aren't at the masjid, you can't do eid salaat.

I know my mother and sister have been going to offer Eid prayer to the Masjid whenever they could, which has been quite regular. I guess it's mainly a preference, and not an obligation on the female's part.

opps  the second option is,  no women should do  eid prayer at home

Yes of course....its the only time of year that I DO go to the masjid...I only go at Eid or when there is a Islamic event happening at the masjid. The rest of the time I pray in my bedroom.